Madison Beach Hotel Land Swap Being Considered, Smaller Than Last Time

Proposed Deal Will Be Subject Of Public Hearing To Be Scheduled; Mere Mention Of The Deal Draws Ire Of One Resident, But Supported By Others At Board Of Selectmen Meeting Monday Night

The town of Madison and Madison Beach Hotel are once again proposing a land swap deal involving property adjacent to West Wharf Beach, one of three town-owned beaches.

This deal would allow Madison Beach Hotel, through a long-term lease or other means, to obtain and use the town-owned grassy area in front of the hotel. In exchange, Madison Beach Hotel would give the town $100,000 and a triangular-shaped property adjacent to West Wharf Beach.

First Selectman Fillmore McPherson, during a meeting of the Board of Selectmen Monday night, said such a deal would accomplish several objectives and solve several problems. 

Heavy run off after rain creates problems for beach, shellfish

One problem is the water that runs down West Wharf Road towards the beach in heavy rainstorms.

"This creates a big gully through the beach that dumps runoff from the road into the shellfish beds, rendering the shellfish beds unusable," McPherson said.

Another problem is that boats moored at West Wharf are tied up with a system of ropes and pulleys that clutter the beach.

"The solution involves having the Madison Beach hotel give us $100,000 to upgrade the road and parking area," McPherson said. "And they would give us this enlarged triangle of beach. In return, we will let the hotel use the grassy strip in front of the hotel, probably through a long-term lease."

Improvements to streetscape envisioned

The $100,000 would be used to improve the entire streetscape in that area, McPherson said, "including parking, and pavers so that the water will soak into the ground and not into the shellfish."

McPherson also said a private group is planning to raise private money to come up with a floating dock off the stone jetty. That would allow the town to get rid of the mooring ropes that currently cross the beach, and it would allow for more boats to be docked there, he said.

"It's a win-win-win situation for the town," McPherson said. "We improve drainage, the situation with the shellfish, the beach, and the moorings for boats and sailboats."

More desirable for young families

McPherson said the improvements would make the beach a much more desirable destination for young families that frequent that beach.

Steve Nikituk, head of the Madison Shellfish Commission, agreed the deal could solve problems with West Wharf, which he said was the premiere shellfishing area in Madison.

"Unfortunately, with the heavy rains, the water in the shellfish area gets contaminated, and we have to close it," he said. "We've had to close it this year. Preventing that run off would go a long way towards improving that."

Madison resident Steve Atkins said a group of town residents was interested in creating a 501(3)c non-profit organization that would raise money to create an improving mooring system and floating docks.

"This is nonsense"

Madison resident Walter Lippman, on the other hand, was initially angry upon hearing about the plans.

Upon hearing about the proposed deal, Lippmann objected, saying that a similar deal had already been turned down at a public hearing.

"We voted down swapping the land," Lippmann said "This is nonsense."

McPherson responded by saying that the deal being discussed Monday was significantly different than the one already considered and turned down at at public hearing.

Selectman Joe MacDougald agreed. "We'll have another meeting, a town meeting. At that town meeting, the town residents can choose to do it or not to do it," he said.

Lippmann expresses concern about West Wharf going into July 4th weekend

Prior to hearing about the new land swap proposal at the Board of Selectmen meeting Monday, Lippman had already expressed concerns about the West Wharf area. During the public comment portion of the meeting, he said he was worried that the ongoing construction was affecting the ability of town residents to use West Wharf beach.

West Wharf is traditionally one of the most popular areas in town to view fireworks, along with the Surf Club.

The construction crews often use the West Wharf lot for parking, Lippmann said, creating problems for town residents who have parking passes and are supposed to be able to park there. He said one of the municipal employees who works at the booth said a town resident was "screaming" about the construction.

"I said call your boss, call the cops," Lippmann told the selectmen during the public comment section of the meeting. "These construction people should be parking at the builder's lot. They should not be parking along West Wharf and Parker."

Construction crews not cleaning up site, Lippmann says

Lippmann also said construction crews were not cleaning up the site, and the lot, as they are supposed to do.

McPherson said police have been asked to patrol the area and to ticket cars that are not parked correctly.

Paula June 29, 2011 at 06:55 PM
$100,000 dollars and a triangle of land that is below the high water line, is not a fair price for our West Wharf Beach. That beach is OURS!!!! Not the selectmen’s and certainly not the Wharf’s. The only thing we would be doing is providing more parking for the Wharf Hotel. This is unacceptable.
Paula June 29, 2011 at 07:01 PM
Also, the town already has a sailing center.....,Why do we have to have two sailing centers in town? This is just greed on Steve Atkins' part
madison mom June 30, 2011 at 04:47 PM
We have already voted, why is this up for discussion again? Also, the police are not patrolling this area. I live close to the hotel and my children and I ride to the beach. My son was almost hit by a speeding construction worker and when I tried to talk to him he became beligerant. As neighbors we would like to see the hotel finished and prosperous, however the builders need to respect their surroundings with the help of our police force and the hotel owner. As West Wharf beach goers we would like to keep the beach as is, natural and quiet.
Pem McNerney June 30, 2011 at 05:06 PM
Hi Paula, if you are going to make negative comments about other individuals, I would appreciate it if you used your first and last name. And, while I don't know Steve Atkins personally, I'm wondering how starting up a non-profit that would benefit the town amounts to greed on his part.
Pem McNerney June 30, 2011 at 05:10 PM
Hi Paula. If you are going to make negative comments about other individuals, I would appreciate it if you used your first and last name. Also, I"m wondering how a proposal by Steve Atkins to start up a non-profit that would benefit the town amounts to greed on his part. That is a serious question, maybe I'm missing something here. Madison mom, I can see why that would be of concern. I'm familiar with the area, used to live a few streets over, and the streets are too small to have construction trucks barreling through. I know the police were giving parking tickets. Maybe a call to them about the speeding might prove beneficial?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »